« June 2004 | Main | August 2004 »
July 16, 2004
Microsoft buys Lookout
Lookout, the search plug-in which I wrote about announced today that they have been this week was acquired by Microsoft.
I'm hoping that this turns out to be a good thing but the fact that it appears to have been rolled into the MSN Search team instead of into the Office team is somewhat worrisome.
Posted July 16, 2004 09:19 AMPosted July 16, 2004 09:19 AM | Permalink
July 14, 2004
Marathon
Oi. What have I gotten myself into? Yesterday, I signed up to run a marathon in January. I've never run more than about three or four miles at once.
Daunting though it may be, I'm doing it through Train to End Stroke, a marathon training team that raises funds for stroke research and education. Two years ago, my father survived a massive cerebellar stroke. That event changed my family life forever.
I'm setting up a Marathon category here and may set up a separate marathon blog. Stay tuned for an ongoing annal of pain and suffering while I teach this aging body to move. ;-)
Posted July 14, 2004 05:58 AMPosted July 14, 2004 05:58 AM | Permalink
The Personal Web
Or, "Why Furl, Lookout, and Google put the smackdown on Backflip, Outlook, and Yahoo"
In a comment to my recent post on Furl, Scott Leslie of Ed Tech Post responded:
"FURL is cool enough, I guess, but I've been a bit surprised by the hype surrounding it, given that web-based bookmark managers have been around for a while now"Scott's right of course, and I've used a gazillion bookmark managers in my day. They all had the same problem: they're bookmark managers. Managing bookmarks sucks. I don't want to manage bookmarks; I want to manage information that interests me.
Bookmark managers almost all suffer from the same conceptual flaw . . . which also happens to be the same conceptual flaw that has plagued organization of other information as well, such as emails.
Take for example, my Outlook/Exchange set up. My job requires I correspond with a couple hundred vendors and academic institutions a year, so, in the past, I've spent a lot of time creating mail folders to keep mail from different sources organized. Forget Outlook's search feature -- with several gigs between my mailbox and archives, Outlook's search performance is near useless.
Enter Lookout, a plug-in for Outlook that indexes your mailbox (and archives and attachments and, if you like, My Documents) in the background. It provides a fairly flexible search interface that responds with googlespeed. Since installing Lookout, I've discovered my Outlook folder heirachy blows chunks. I don't need it anymore. A good search query and I can find most any email I've sent or received via Outlook in the last five years in seconds. Which suddenly means that the four gigs of mail folders and archives ceases to be an almost-static hunk of data and becomes knowledge that I can use.
The lesson (and the point of this post)? A good search obliviates the need for a hierarchy. The conceptual flaw inherent ot most email clients and bookmark managers is the assumption the best way for to make the information useful is to organize it (usually manually) into categories or hierarchies. To be fair, this is probably less a conceptual flaw, than a historical technical limitation -- you need a certain level of processing power and storage space.
Solving for this allowed Google to take a commanding lead in the "finding information" field. At one point in the history of the Web, human-managed hierarchical directories like Yahoo were still a valuable method to get to information kind of like what you wanted. Enter Google. By applying brute force processing power, suddenly a search turns up relevant results, so I don't need the legion of Yahoo indexers as much anymore. (Librarians shudder at this line of thought.)
Furl is more valuable than other bookmark managers, because it indexes the full text of every page I "furl." Not just the page title, not just the metadata I add, but the full text of the page. I quickly did away with categorizing "furled" pages once I realized I can use Furl's fairly decent, Google-like query syntax. That's great because heirarchies are bitch to maintain and keep relevant (just ask Yahoo). Furl is like Lookout for bookmarks. Or, more to the point, it's like Google for bookmarks.
The least important thing Furl does is help you manage bookmarks. More interesting and useful are the social aspects (and, in general, I'm a great fan of recommendation engines of any sort). Clay Shirky hit on these social aspects yesterday as well, posting about social link management on , as did Peter Capula in a post on social bookmarking and other stuff on the Social Software Weblog.
However, the most important thing Furl does is allow you to carve out a sub-section of the web that you're interested in and deal with that sub-section in a Google-like manner, meaning being able to search the full text of the web pages. John Battelle hit the line drive on this back in April, calling it the Personal Web. Bookmarks are a list of page titles. A Personal Web -- like a Furl collection -- is a repository of content. It's the difference between being the card catalog and being the library.
Posted July 14, 2004 05:33 AMPosted July 14, 2004 05:33 AM | Permalink | Comments (5)